Search for cancer genes unlikely to be successful

	Tweet

The hunt to find common genes that are associated with cancer is unlikely to be successful, say experts in this week’s British Medical Journal.

Huge resources are being invested in the search for common inherited genetic variants that increase susceptibility to cancer. One US project, for example, will cost $14m. But devoting a large research effort to searching for common cancer susceptibility genes has several problems, write authors Stuart Baker and Jaakko Kaprio.

The first is that recent research suggests these genes are unlikely to exist or, if they do, are unlikely to have much of an effect on the incidence of cancer.

A second reason to play down the role of common susceptibility genes is studies suggesting that environmental, dietary, or lifestyle changes have a large effect on the incidence of cancer. These studies show changes in incidence within one or two generations, which is probably too quick to be related to the introduction of new genes.

A final reason to be sceptical comes from results from a study of cancers in twins. By analysing data from identical and non-identical twins, the authors showed that genetic susceptibility made only a small to moderate contribution to the incidence of cancer.

Studies that have shown links between common genes and cancer may be due to bias.

But, even if susceptibility genes were identified, showing clinical benefit would still be difficult, and further large trials would be needed, they add.

“The search for common cancer susceptibility genes faces important methodological and practical challenges for cancer prevention, given the small chance that such genetic variants exist and the difficulty and expense of proving substantial clinical benefit if they do exist,” they conclude. “Enthusiasm for this new field of research should not precipitate unwarranted expectations.”

http://www.bmj.com

RELATED STORIES:
New insights into how cells repair damaged DNA   Cancer rates on the rise in young people   29% of Cancer Studies Report Conflict of Interest   Hereditary cancer risk   Teenagers and young adults more likely to survive cancer in Australia than in the USA   Asthma gene variants may cut risk of brain cancer   Discovery Could Lead to Early Cancer Detection, Prevention   Researchers unveil vital key to cancer   Therapeutic gene suspected to cause cancer   Arsenic implicated in etiology of cancer   Diabetes drug kills cancer stem cells in combination treatment in mice   Alcohol and Cancer: Know Your Limit   Treatment resistance in some cancer cells may be reversible   Using PET/CT Imaging, Researchers Can Tell After a Single Treatment Whether Chemotherapy is Working   Sensitizing tumor response to cancer therapy   Viruses against cancer   DNA differences may influence risk of Hodgkin disease   Europe aims to reduce cancer deaths by 15 pct by 2020   Novel therapy may prove effective in treatment of 30 percent of cancers   Statins don’t protect against cancer: study   Cancer deaths fall in US for first time   Acupuncture, massage helpful after cancer surgery

Comments

[ + Post Your Own ]

Now you're in the public comment zone. What follows is not Armenian Medical Network's stuff; it comes from other people and we don't vouch for it. A reminder: By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.

There are no comments for this entry yet. [ + Comment here + ]