Newer cervical cancer test no better than the old?

	Tweet

Findings from a review of published studies suggest that the newer liquid-based cervical cancer tests are no better than the conventional Pap test for checking for signs of cervical cancer. However, definitive research in this area is lacking, so the authors are calling for large randomized controlled trials.

Developed as an alternative to the traditional Pap smear, liquid-based “cytology” uses a thin layer of cells that yields results faster than the Pap test and is thought to be more sensitive than the Pap smear. The newer tests are also believed to generate fewer unsatisfactory slide results. While some countries have adopted liquid-based cytology as a screening method, controversy regarding its benefits persists.

In a review of 56 studies, including more than one million slides, that looked at liquid-based and conventional cytology, Dr. Elizabeth Davey, from the University of Sydney in Australia, and colleagues found little differences in the two approaches.

They report in the Lancet this week that the liquid-based tests did not detect any more serious cervical lesions, which could lead to cancer, than the conventional tests. Liquid-based and conventional cytology also produced a similar number of unsatisfactory slides.

However, only four studies had sufficient data to determine the sensitivity and specificity of both types of cytology, suggesting, the researchers conclude, that much more study is needed before firm conclusions can be drawn.

SOURCE: The Lancet January 14, 2006.

RELATED STORIES:
Health Groups Issue Cervical Cancer Screening Guidelines   Weakened RNA Interference Reduces Survival in Ovarian Cancer   HPV testing: Indications of a benefit in primary screening   HPV tests better for cervical screening - experts   Coils almost halve risk of cervical cancer: study   Cervical cancer screening: Too many are left unprotected   Study determines costs of breast and cervical cancer detection among low-income women   Annual cervical cancer screening persists, despite recommended guidelines   Girls should get cervical cancer vaccine, panel says   Study indicates vaccine prevents cervical cancer   Cervical cancer vaccines may cut need for screening   Cervical cancer vaccines in development   Urinary tract cancer associated with Chinese herbal products containing aristolochic acid   Singapore questions cervical cancer vaccine for teens   A Cervical Cancer Screening Month Resolution   Cervical cancer chemo easier on black women: study   Cervical cancer vaccine can protect men from HPV   High HPV Concentrations, Smoking Significantly Raise Risks of Cancer   FDA approval of Gardasil to prevent cervical cancer   Higher Risk for Cervical Cancer Seen Among Women Infected with Multiple HPV Types   Risk of cervical and other cancers after treatment of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia   HPV screen-and treat-intervention effective in cervical cancer prevention

Comments

[ + Post Your Own ]

Now you're in the public comment zone. What follows is not Armenian Medical Network's stuff; it comes from other people and we don't vouch for it. A reminder: By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.

There are no comments for this entry yet. [ + Comment here + ]