Error rate higher in breast imaging reports generated by automatic speech recognition

	Tweet

Breast imaging reports generated using an automatic speech recognition system are nearly six times more likely to contain major errors than those generated with conventional dictation transcription, a new study in Canada shows.

The study reviewed 615 reports of complex cases discussed on multidisciplinary team rounds: 308 reports generated with automatic speech recognition (the radiologist dictates the report and software immediately transcribes the report on a computer screen) and 307 reports generated with conventional dictation transcription (the radiologist dictates the report and a team transcribes and reviews the report). “Our study found that at least one major error was found in 23% of automatic speech recognition (ASR) reports compared to 4% of conventional dictation transcription report,” said Anabel Scaranelo, MD, of the University Health Network in Toronto, Canada. Major errors were described as those errors that had an impact on the understanding of the report and errors affecting patient management, such as an incorrect unit of measurement (for example, millimeter instead of centimeter) or a missing or added “no” (for example, malignancy instead of no malignancy).

The error rate was even higher if breast MRI reports were looked at separately, said Dr. Scaranelo. The major error rate was 35% for ASR reports and 7% for conventional reports, she said. “We think this is because MRI reports are more complex, with more description,” Dr. Scaranelo said. 

Native language had no affect on the ASR report error rate, said Dr. Scaranelo. “We thought that there may be a higher error rate for non-native English speakers because the software works with voice recognition, but that didn’t happen,” she said. The ASR system is fed with several hours of dictation from the radiologists, and it appears to have “learned” from the voice data that was input, she says.

ASR is commonly used in several countries, said Dr. Scaranelo. “The results of our study emphasize the need for careful editing of reports generated with ASR. They also show a strong need for standardized templates and use of structured reports, especially for breast MRI,” she said.

The study is published in the October, 2011 American Journal of Roentgenology.

###

Contact: Keri Sperry

703-858-4315
American Roentgen Ray Society

RELATED STORIES:
Wife’s breast cancer hard on some spouses: study   Breast Cancer Patients with BRCA Mutations at 4x Higher Risk for Contralateral Breast Cancer   COX-2 blockers may curb breast cancer risk   Surgical breast biopsy not overused, study suggests   Mammograms May Detect Some Cancers That Would Have Regressed   New Universal Breast Cancer Marker Predicts Recurrence and Clinical Outcome   New Treatment Paradigms for Breast Cancer: Managing the Flow of New Data   Kinetic variable most useful for identifying malignant MRI-detected breast lesions identified   First prospective analysis links breast and pancreatic cancer risk with lynch syndrome   Health providers should emphasize breast cancer screening, Wayne State University research finds   Study finds it’s safe to treat HER2-positive breast cancer with trastuzumab and adjuvant radiation   Why are African Americans less Likely to Survive Certain Cancers?   UT MD Anderson study finds advances in breast cancer don’t extend to older women   Diet may lower breast cancer risk before menopause   Exercise helps breast cancer patients avoid anemia   Moderate Red Wine Drinking May Help Cut Women’s Breast Cancer Risk   Cancer cells in blood can identify risk of recurrence in breast cancer   Predicting breast cancer patient outcome: MUHC researchers identify new genes   IOM Report On Breast Cancer And The Environment   Breast cancer deaths decline more slowly for some   Preschool diet linked to cancer risk   Breast Cancer Impact on Same Sex Couples

Comments

[ + Post Your Own ]

Now you're in the public comment zone. What follows is not Armenian Medical Network's stuff; it comes from other people and we don't vouch for it. A reminder: By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.

There are no comments for this entry yet. [ + Comment here + ]