Breast Cancer - MRI Does Not Help, Even Though Usage Grows

MRI ( magnetic resonance imaging) is increasingly used to help doctors decide on treatment options for breast cancer patients, despite there being very little evidence that this type of imaging has any benefit, researchers from the Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center in New York, USA, reported in The Lancet series of articles.

Over recent years the use of MRI scans has been widely adopted by clinical practices, because of the assumption that its increased sensitivity at identifying cancer will improve patients’ outcomes. Monica Morrow and team set out to determine whether this assumption was valid. They researched peer-reviewed published articles over the last decade.

They discovered that although MRI proves to be a valuable tool for screening women with a genetically high risk of breast cancer, the evidence for screening those in the general population is limited. They also found limited evidence to support that routine MRI screening before breast-conserving surgery improves patient selection, lowers the risk of local breast cancer recurrences, or reduces surgical procedures. 

The team noted that sufficient evidence exists for MRI to be a beneficial screening tool in women with a genetically high risk of breast cancer, due to family history or known gene mutation, and that it can accurately detect tumors that have been overlooked by mammography and ultrasound, although nobody really knows whether this improved detection has an impact on survival or not.

The researchers say that there is no evidence that the increased sensitivity of using MRI scans to examine women before surgery results in better surgical treatment or prognosis.

They add that in addition, the impact of MRI on longer-term outcomes cannot be determined due to the limited number of trials and the poor quality in many of these human studies. Long-term outcomes include the incidence of cancer affecting the other breast (contra lateral cancer) or recurrence in the affected breast (ipsilateral cancer).

According to the researchers, MRI screening proves to be more reliable at evaluating the extent of residual disease after, and in response to preoperative chemotherapy compared with traditional examinations, such as physical examination, mammography, and ultrasonography. However, it is unclear whether this results in an improved ability to select suitable patients for breast-conserving therapy.

In an Abstract in the journal, the authors concluded:

###

Written by Petra Rattue

RELATED STORIES:
U-M researchers find genetic rearrangements driving 5 to 7 percent of breast cancers   Fertility procedures need not delay breast cancer treatment for younger women   Mammograms may be worth risks for some in their 40s   WellPoint adopting parts of breast cancer act   Women at risk of breast cancer decline tamoxifen   Understanding the role of androgen receptor signaling in breast cancer   FDA Panel OKs Ultrasound to Screen Dense Breasts   A new breast cancer susceptibility gene   Common transplant drug inhibits breast cancer growth, UNC laboratory study shows   Hispanic Women and Breast Cancer: An Understudied Group   Breast cancer gene carriers need dual screening   Alcohol may raise chances of breast cancer return   Diet plus exercise up survival after breast cancer   Breast density may increase cancer risk   Vitamin A derivative provides clues to better breast cancer drugs   Study finds mammography screening reduces breast cancer mortality   Cell Study Finds Receptor Can Fight Tamoxifen-resistant Breast Cancer Cells   FDA Approves Test for HER2 Gene in Breast Cancer Tissue   Breast density associated with increased risk of cancer recurrence   Breast cancer and pregnancy   V. Suzanne Klimberg, M.D. Authors Book on Breast Surgical Techniques   Blood thinners like aspirin may fight cancer: study

Now you're in the public comment zone. What follows is not Armenian Medical Network's stuff; it comes from other people and we don't vouch for it. A reminder: By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.

There are no comments for this entry yet. [ + Comment here + ]