Wide Variations in Appropriateness of Rectal Cancer Surgery Across England

A substantial proportion of rectal cancer patients are receiving inappropriate surgical care, because of wide variations in practice across England, reveals research published ahead of print in the journal Gut.

The variation was not associated with how far the disease had advanced or how old the patient was, the data showed.

The findings are based on information obtained from the eight cancer registries in England, which track the progress of all patients with cancer, and NHS hospital data on admissions and treatment between1998–2004. 

During this period, 58 290 patients were diagnosed with rectal cancer in England, of whom 31 223 underwent major abdominal surgery in 153 hospitals to treat their disease.

Around 13 000 people are diagnosed with rectal cancer every year in the UK, and the disease has an annual death toll of around 5000.

There are several different surgical approaches to rectal cancer treatment, the most common of which used to be abdominoperineal excision, or APE for short.

This involves the removal of the anal sphincter, necessitating the permanent use of a colostomy bag. But mounting evidence indicates that although APE is unavoidable in some patients, it should not be the preferred procedure for most of them.

Furthermore, the evidence shows that APE is also associated with higher rates of recurrence and poorer survival than a procedure called anterior resection, or AR for short.

The Department of Health has published guidance, encouraging surgeons, wherever possible, to use alternative methods and adopt AR, which obviates the need for a colostomy bag.

The figures showed that many surgeons had taken the evidence on board, because rates of APE fell from almost one in three procedures (30.5%) in 1998 to almost one in four (23%) in 2004.

But there were wide variations in the use of APE among different cancer networks, individual surgeons as well as hospital trusts, where rates varied from 8.5% to almost 53%.

In 1998, one in three patients were also operated on a by a surgeon who performed fewer than seven rectal cancer procedures in a year. By 2004, this had fallen to around one in four (26.5%).

Patients treated by a specialist surgeon undertaking seven or more cases of rectal cancer a year were 23% less likely to be treated with APE than those with less experience.

The figures also revealed that those living in the most deprived areas of the country were significantly more likely to receive an APE than those living in the most affluent areas.

There were no obvious clinical reasons for these discrepancies, the findings showed.

APE may not only spell poorer quality of life for patients, but it is also more expensive, in terms of the maintenance costs of colostomies and the treatment of recurrent disease, say the authors.

“These problems must be addressed if the government is to attain its aims of ensuring a high quality of cancer care for all,” they conclude.

Source: British Medical Journal

RELATED STORIES:
Daily drinking may raise risk of several cancers   Lights, Camera, Colonoscopy: What to Expect When Your Doctor Wants an Inside Look   March is National Colorectal Cancer Awareness Month   A New Way to Treat Colon Cancer?   Lower socioeconomic status decreases chances of early detection and survival of colorectal cancer   Diabetes & hyper-insulinemia as predictors of colorectal cancer risk   Can a Mediterranean Diet Help Prevent Colon Cancer?   CT scans may predict survival in colorectal cancer   LOH analysis on 4q in sporadic colorectal carcinoma   Sex, Age and Ethnicity Associated With Colorectal Cancer Survival   Pain pills may cut risk of bowel cancer: study   Age likely a factor in colon cancer chemotherapy   Colon cancer risk in women does not seem to be reduced by physical activity   Smoking Related to Subset of Colorectal Cancers with Absent DNA Repair Proteins   How to Lower Costs, Waiting Times for Colonoscopies   Studies lend insights into colorectal cancer screening   Long-term aspirin lowers colon cancer risk   Diet, smoking, exercise key in colon cancer risk   Colorectal Cancer Screening Rates Still Too Low   Regular Screenings and Healthy Living Reduce Colon Cancer Risk   Study confirms red meat link with bowel cancer   Study Sets Treatment Standard for Elderly with Colon Cancer

Comments

[ + Post Your Own ]

Now you're in the public comment zone. What follows is not Armenian Medical Network's stuff; it comes from other people and we don't vouch for it. A reminder: By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.

There are no comments for this entry yet. [ + Comment here + ]