Exercise Tolerance is Good Screening Test for Chest Pain Patients

	Tweet

Mayo Clinic researchers studying patients in the emergency department with acute chest pain report in the current issue of Mayo Clinic Proceedings that exercise treadmill testing (ETT) was often sufficient for evaluation.

Not all patients can be evaluated this way. However, patients who met the physicians’ criteria were able to be evaluated by the less costly method of exercise treadmill testing. Those who weren’t candidates for this testing could be admitted to the hospital and didn’t benefit very much from more costly stress imaging testing in the emergency department.

The evaluation of patients who come to the emergency department with chest pain is a major challenge. A system that evaluates symptoms and estimates the risk of each patient is useful in determining treatment protocols and the need for additional tests.

“Our strategy with exercise treadmill testing in selected patients helped us choose patients for hospital admission in a cost-effective and safe way,” said Raymond Gibbons, M.D., Mayo Clinic cardiologist and one of the primary authors of the study.

The Mayo Clinic study looked at 212 intermediate-risk patients with unstable angina who were evaluated with chest pain units (CPU), a triage strategy to determine the severity of a patient’s condition. Those patients were compared with 212 who were routinely admitted to Saint Mary’s Hospital in Rochester.

The researchers found that those who were eligible for the treadmill testing frequently had normal results and could be safely discharged from the emergency room without any significant events in the following six months. Those who were not eligible for the treadmill testing, such as those not capable of exercising, were frequently abnormal by stress imaging and usually admitted to the hospital.

“Referring this high-risk group for further stress imaging adds little benefit and is not cost-effective, primarily because of the high rate of admission after equivocal or abnormal results from stress imaging studies,” said Dr. Gibbons.

Other authors of the study include: Gautam Ramakrishna, M.D.; Alan Zinsmeister, Ph.D.; Thomas Allison, Ph.D.; and Peter Smars, M.D., of Mayo Clinic. James Milavetz, M.D., is now with Utah Cardiology in Ogden, Roger Evans, PhD, is now a self-employed consultant in Rochester, Minn, and Michael Farkouh, M.D., is now with the New York University Medical Center.

In an editorial in the March issue of Mayo Clinic Proceedings, Ezra Amsterdam, M.D., and William Lewis, M.D., of the UC Davis School of Medicine and UC Davis Medical Center in Sacramento, Calif., note the challenge of providing optimal care while enhancing cost effectiveness and resource utilization for patients who are experiencing chest pain.

The editorial writers support as “more practical and focused” the study’s conclusion that the “results suggest that a community hospital that is planning to set up a CPU may benefit more by developing expertise in exercise treadmill testing rather than in allocating resources to stress imaging.”

Drs. Amsterdam and Lewis conclude that the optimal strategy for assessing patients with chest pain has not yet been realized, but investigators will continue toward that goal with studies such as the Mayo study.

SOURCE: Mayo Clinic

RELATED STORIES:
Study shows premature babies can feel pain   Redheads especially fearful of dental pain   Advice as good as physiotherapy for back pain: study   Commonly Used Pain Medications Do Not Prevent Alzheimers Disease   Painful sweating reported after wart removal   Children’s pain in hospital undertreated: study   Study Probes Obesity Link to Fibromyalgia   Chest pain? Don’t delay calling 911   Combination therapy effective for neurological pain   Music Quiets Pain After Surgery   Gene that controls chronic pain identified   Migraine Increases Risk of Severe Skin Sensitivity and Pain

Comments

[ + Post Your Own ]

Now you're in the public comment zone. What follows is not Armenian Medical Network's stuff; it comes from other people and we don't vouch for it. A reminder: By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.

There are no comments for this entry yet. [ + Comment here + ]