Gender Identity Disorder - Treatment of the Child - Psychotherapy

	Tweet

There is a large case report literature on the treatment of children with GID using psychoanalysis, psychoanalytic psychotherapy, or psychotherapy, some of which is quite detailed and rich in content. The psychoanalytic treatment literature is more diverse than the behavior therapy literature, including varied theoretical approaches to understanding the putative etiology of GID (e.g., classical, object relations, and self psychology); nevertheless, a number of recurring themes can be gleaned from this case report literature.

Psychoanalytic clinicians generally emphasize that the cross-gender behavior emerges during the “preoedipal” years; accordingly, they stress the importance of understanding how the GID relates to other developmental phenomena salient during these years - for example, attachment (object) relations and the emergence of the autonomous self. Oedipal issues are also deemed important, but these are understood within the context of prior developmental interferences and conflicts. Psychoanalytic clinicians also place great weight on the child’s overall adaptive functioning, which they view as critical in determining the therapeutic approach to the specific referral problem.

Apart from the general developmental perspective inherent to a psychoanalytic understanding of psychopathology, one might also add to this the general developmental perspective on gender development (Ruble and Martin 1998). Many developmentalists, for example, note that the first signs of normative gender development appear during the toddler years, including the ability to correctly self-label oneself as a boy or a girl. Some authors have even postulated a sensitive period for gender identity formation (Money et al. 1957), which suggests a period of time in which there is a greater malleability or plasticity in the direction that gender identity can move (Coates 1990). Thus, early gender identity formation intersects quite neatly with analytic views on the early development of the sense of self in more global terms. It is likely, therefore, that the putative pathogenic mechanisms identified in the development of GID are likely to have a greater impact only if they occur during the alleged sensitive period for gender identity formation (Coates and Wolfe 1995).

Some of the more common themes identified in the analytic literature are reviewed below.

RELATED STORIES:
Prevention of Gender Identity Disorder (Transsexualism) in Adulthood   Treatment of Distress Associated With Gender Identity Disorder   Gender Identity Disorder: Eclectic Psychotherapy   Gender Identity Disorder in Children and Adolescents - Group Therapy   Rationales for Therapeutic Intervention   Treatment of Underlying Psychopathology   Gender Identity Disorder: Father-Child Relations   Gender Identity Disorder in Children and Adolescents   Gender Identity Disorder - Treatment of the Adolescent   Gender Identity Disorder - Treatment of the Child   Gender Identity Disorder: Mother-Child Relations   Gender Identity Disorder in Children and Adolescents - Treatment of the Parents   Prevention of Homosexuality in Adulthood

Comments

[ + Post Your Own ]

Now you're in the public comment zone. What follows is not Armenian Medical Network's stuff; it comes from other people and we don't vouch for it. A reminder: By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.

Psychoanalytic clinicians generally EMPHASIZE that the cross-gender behavior emerges during the “preoedipal” years, accordingly, they stress the importance of understanding how the GID Relates to other developmental phenomena salient during these years - for example, attachment (object) relations and the Emergence of the autonomous self.

posted by Thecounselor on 11/10/2009 at 10:45 pm -08:00