Should We Screen People for Depression?

	Tweet

Screening for depression is unlikely to be an effective way to improve the mental wellbeing of the population, say researchers in this week’s BMJ.

Nevertheless, it may soon become health policy in England and Wales as primary care doctors are rewarded for screening under their new contract.

Using UK National Screening Committee criteria, the research team scrutinised the rationale and evidence to support such screening.

They found that, although depression qualifies as a major public health problem, criteria regarding test performance, acceptability, and treatment benefits were not met.

Other key criteria are unlikely to be achieved, say the authors. For example, that the benefit from screening should outweigh the harm and that the screening programme should be cost effective.

Opportunistic screening and population level screening for depression do not fulfil the criteria of the National Screening Committee, say the authors. However, the assumption has been made that screening for depression should be recommended.

Screening should only be considered as part of a package of enhanced care. Without this, moves to implement screening will be associated with increased costs and no benefit, they conclude.

An accompanying editorial argues that it is time we treated depression as the chronic disease that it is.

Click here to view full paper: http://press.psprings.co.uk/bmj/april/ac1027.pdf

RELATED STORIES:
Do Mentally Ill Patients’ Own Perceptions Affect Their Well-Being?   The Conflict of Reward in Depression   Mental tests reveal fall risk for older Australians   Higher rates of mental illness among the homeless in Western countries   Depression and distress not detected in majority of patients seen by nurses—new study   Anabolic steroids flip the adolescent brain’s switch for aggression   Earlier bedtimes may help protect adolescents against depression and suicidal thoughts   Study Links Shorter Sleep Durations with Greater Risks of Mental Distress in Young Adults   Mutations on 3 genes could predispose people to suicidal behaviour   Gene variant affects response to antidepressants   Virtual Communities May Foster Mental Health in Severely Ill Kids   Effective Treatments Available for Anxiety Disorder   Teen Media Exposure Associated With Depression Symptoms in Young Adulthood   Talk therapy effective treatment for seasonal affective disorder   Use of medication for insomnia or anxiety increases mortality risk by 36 percent

Comments

[ + Post Your Own ]

Now you're in the public comment zone. What follows is not Armenian Medical Network's stuff; it comes from other people and we don't vouch for it. A reminder: By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.

There are no comments for this entry yet. [ + Comment here + ]