Are personality disorders caused by environmental or constitutional factors?

	Tweet

The DSM-IV avoids the question by taking an empirical, atheoretical approach; the disorders are defined by descriptive criteria emphasizing observable behaviors. In the past, personality was traditionally viewed as a product of upbringing, whereas the major mental illnesses were thought to be related to biologic vulnerabilities. These issues are now understood to be much more complex, and a substantial body of evidence suggests that both biologic and environmental variables play important interacting roles in personality development and disorders.

A familial relationship may exist between schizophrenia and cluster A personality disorders, especially schizotypal personality disorder. Family studies also have suggested a hereditary component to antisocial personality disorder. Borderline personality disorder clusters in families, although this is not clearly genetically determined.

Some axis I illnesses such as depression are present at elevated rates in families of personality disordered probands, suggesting that in some cases personality disorder symptoms may be inherited subsyndromal forms of axis I problems.

Data supporting the role of environmental factors are strongest in the cluster B group, including high rates of childhood sexual and physical abuse as well as elevated rates of childhood stressors such as divorce, parental loss, inadequate parenting, frequent moves, and institutional placements. Although the association between borderline personality disorder and childhood abuse is the most strongly established (70–80% prevalence in most studies), other personality disorders have been estimated to have childhood abuse prevalence rates of approximately 50% compared with estimates of 20–40% in mixed psychiatric populations and 10–15% in the general population.

RELATED STORIES:
Low work status, job worries boost depression risk   Depression in kids may precede or follow bullying   Stress response predictor in police officers may indicate those at high risk for PTSD   Visual pattern preference may be indicator of autism in toddlers   Combination of Medication and Psychotherapy Appears Most Effective for Treatment of Depressed Teens   Combat may raise eating disorder risk in women   Socially Active and Not Easily Stressed? You May Not Develop Dementia   Depression treatment, increased physical activity in African Americans may reduce heart disease and   Antidepressants can cause withdrawal in newborns   Extended-Treatment With Combination Medication for Opioid-Addicted Youths Shows Benefit   Drug seen effective in personality disorder   Depression may up risk of dementia in men   Latino Teens Happier, Healthier If Families Embrace Biculturalism   Shock therapy seen to improve quality of life   Low Testosterone Levels Associated With Depression in Older Men

Comments

[ + Post Your Own ]

Now you're in the public comment zone. What follows is not Armenian Medical Network's stuff; it comes from other people and we don't vouch for it. A reminder: By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.

There are no comments for this entry yet. [ + Comment here + ]