Telling anorexics about bone harm may spur change

Key points
- Informing young women with Anorexia about their future risk of developing the brittle bone disease Osteoporosis may lead some to make healthy changes, such as increasing their calcium intake, according to a new study .
- "Having a bone density measurement and the discussion around the results may lead to positive changes if approached in a sensitive and caring manner by a health provider," said Dr.
- In her study, "many participants expressed that they recalled discussions about healthy steps to good bone health and were able to engage in some of these behaviors later when they got better psychologically."
- Much of a person's bone density is determined by genetics and research shows that people gain at least half of their bone density and peak bone mass during the adolescent years.
Informing young women with Anorexia about their future risk of developing the brittle bone disease Osteoporosis may lead some to make healthy changes, such as increasing their calcium intake, according to a new study .
"Having a bone density measurement and the discussion around the results may lead to positive changes if approached in a sensitive and caring manner by a health provider," said Dr. Catherine M. Gordon, of Children's Hospital Boston.
In her study, "many participants expressed that they recalled discussions about healthy steps to good bone health and were able to engage in some of these behaviors later when they got better psychologically."
Much of a person's bone density is determined by genetics and research shows that people gain at least half of their bone density and peak bone mass during the adolescent years. Teen girls and young women with Anorexia Nervosa, however, are known to experience early bone loss and to have a higher risk of bone fracture than their peers.
In fact, findings from 2001 report indicated that more than half of the non-recovered anorexic women involved in a 4-year study had significant bone loss in the spine, and more than 20 percent had Osteoporosis - at an average age of about 25.
Some health care professionals conduct bone mineral density tests on their anorexic patients to alert them to the effects of disordered eating on their bone health. Gordon and her team investigated the extent to which the results of such bone tests impact the eating behaviors of anorexic patients.
They studied 19 women, ages 16 to 24, who had exhibited symptoms of anorexia nervosa for up to 10 years. The women either participated in focus groups or in individual hour-long interviews, answering questions similar to those posed to the focus groups.
Overall, 14 women reported receiving abnormal results from their bone mineral density test, the report indicates.
The experience of having their bones tested elicited a variety of reactions from the study participants. Some said they were frightened, one said she was intimidated, and another said that the need for the test was a "wake-up call," Gordon and colleagues report in the journal, Clinics in Sports Medicine.
Ten women took action upon receiving the results of their bone test. Several of these women increased their intake of calcium or calcium supplements while others said they had gained weight, started taking birth control pills to resume their menstrual cycle, or had become more compliant with their estrogen replacement therapy.
"Our results demonstrate that performing bone density measurements could be an important tool in the ongoing management of patients with anorexia nervosa," Gordon and her team write.
Written and revised by
Gerald Hurowitz, M.D.
Our doctors write and review articles for accuracy and keep them up to date.
health.am provides general information, not medical advice. Always consult a qualified health professional about your own health.
Explore health topics
More in this topic
Weight & Nutrition →
NewsDifferent fat types can help or hinder obese girls' bone health
According to a new study accepted for publication in The Endocrine Society's Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism (JCEM), obese teenage girls with a greater ratio of visceral fat (fat around internal organs)…
2 March 2010
NewsResearch reveals link between beer and bone health
A new study suggests that beer is a significant source of dietary silicon, a key ingredient for increasing bone mineral density. Researchers from the Department of Food Science & Technology at the University of…
9 February 2010
NewsNew evidence that green tea may help improve bone health
Researchers in Hong Kong are reporting new evidence that green tea — one of the most popular beverages consumed worldwide and now available as a dietary supplement — may help improve bone health. They found that the tea…


