Brain processes whistled language just as spoken

Key points
- Like Snow White's seven dwarfs, shepherds on one of Spain's Canary Islands whistle while they work and use the sound to communicate over long distances.
- No one knows how long the shepherds on the island of La Gomera have used the rare whistled language called the Silbo Gomero, but American and Spanish researchers said on Wednesday that the brain processes it like a spoken language.
- "We found that the same areas (of the brain) that are activated for language are also activated for the Silbo," Manuel Carreiras, of the University of La Laguna on the island of Tenerife, told AMN Health.
- He and his colleague David Corina, of the University of Washington in the United States, used functional magnetic resonance imaging to compare how the brain is activated in five Spanish speakers and five shepherds who spoke Spanish and Silbo.
Like Snow White's seven dwarfs, shepherds on one of Spain's Canary Islands whistle while they work and use the sound to communicate over long distances.
No one knows how long the shepherds on the island of La Gomera have used the rare whistled language called the Silbo Gomero, but American and Spanish researchers said on Wednesday that the brain processes it like a spoken language.
"We found that the same areas (of the brain) that are activated for language are also activated for the Silbo," Manuel Carreiras, of the University of La Laguna on the island of Tenerife, told AMN Health.
He and his colleague David Corina, of the University of Washington in the United States, used functional magnetic resonance imaging to compare how the brain is activated in five Spanish speakers and five shepherds who spoke Spanish and Silbo.
During two tasks, the volunteers listened to sentences in the two languages while the researchers monitored their brain activity.
When the whistlers listened to Silbo sentences, regions in the left side of their brain were activated, including areas linked to language production and comprehension, along with a region in the right hemisphere thought to be associated with linguistic processing.
The brains of the Spanish speakers did not show the same response, which suggests they did not recognize Silbo, according to the scientists, who reported their findings in the journal Nature.
When only Spanish sentences were played, both groups showed the same pattern of bilateral brain activation.
"Our results provide more evidence about the flexibility of human capacity for language in a variety of forms," Corina said.
"The non-Silbo speakers were not recognizing Silbo as a language. They had nothing to grab on to so multiple areas of their brains were activated. But the Silbadores (whistlers) were analyzing differently, as a language, and engaging those areas associated with language," he added in a statement.
The Silbo, which is thought to have been brought to the island by Berbers from North Africa, condenses Spanish into two vowels and four consonants.
Whistled languages are also used in Greece, Turkey, China and Mexico, according to Corina.
Written and revised by
David Cohen, M.D.
Our doctors write and review articles for accuracy and keep them up to date.
health.am provides general information, not medical advice. Always consult a qualified health professional about your own health.
Explore health topics
More in this topic
Brain & Nerves →
NewsResearchers question what happens in the brain when we think
New research from Lund University in Sweden questions the prevailing doctrine on how the brain absorbs and processes information. The idea that the brain has a mechanism to maintain activity at the lowest possible level…
26 June 2015
NewsCannabis Harms Brain, Imaging Shows
The heavy, long-term use of cannabis is associated with negative changes in parts of the brain not previously implicated, and is linked to deficits in learning and memory, new research suggests. "In light of a current…
10 June 2015
NewsAcademic struggles more common in children with epilepsy who have brain surgery
A new study by a University of Toronto Mississauga researcher has taken the first-ever look at the academic outcomes of children with epilepsy who have had brain surgery, and found that they have a higher chance of…
3 June 2015



