Sugar more toxic than alcohol, scientists claim

Key points
- We've seen what excessive amounts of alcohol can do to the body, remember Nicolas Cage's performance in Leaving Las Vegas?
- Scientists Robert Lustig, Laura Schmidt and Claire Brindis from the University of California, San Francisco are calling for governments worldwide to regulate foods and drinks with 'added sugar' as strictly as alcohol and tobacco.
- Lustig and his colleagues are prompting debate as they argue, citing numerous studies and statistics that indicating that sugar has a bigger impact on public health than alcohol and tobacco, as fructose can trigger processes that lead to a chronic disease pandemic including liver toxicity.
- No stranger to making provocative statements, in 2009 Dr.
We've seen what excessive amounts of alcohol can do to the body, remember Nicolas Cage's performance in Leaving Las Vegas? Cirrhosis of the liver, behavioural changes, and finally complete metabolic shutdown. We know that alcohol in excess is toxic but a group of scientists are claiming that 'added sugar' is more detrimental to our health.
Scientists Robert Lustig, Laura Schmidt and Claire Brindis from the University of California, San Francisco are calling for governments worldwide to regulate foods and drinks with 'added sugar' as strictly as alcohol and tobacco. They are also calling for the sugary foods to be banned in and around schools, placing age limits on purchases as not only is it taxing to the liver, causing fatty liver disease, and ultimately leading to insulin resistance, but claim it to be the underlying causes of obesity and diabetes.
Dr. Lustig and his colleagues are prompting debate as they argue, citing numerous studies and statistics that indicating that sugar has a bigger impact on public health than alcohol and tobacco, as fructose can trigger processes that lead to a chronic disease pandemic including liver toxicity. They concede that a little is not a problem, but a lot kills - slowly.
No stranger to making provocative statements, in 2009 Dr. Lustig's lecture "Sugar: The Bitter Truth," was posted on YouTube and has been viewed by almost two million people, not bad for a 90-minute discussion on the evils of sugar.
Many health experts are disagreeing with the controversial article published in the journal Nature, such as Dr Alan Barclay, head of research at the Australian Diabetes Foundation. He told Lifehacker that "many of the statements simply do not apply to Australia and on certain issues there is little evidence to support their views. Sugar is not the issue" he said, "it is far more complicated than that."
How to limit your salt and sugar intake Eat as close to nature as possible. Include, in your diet, fresh vegies, some whole fruit, lean meats and whoelgrains. Processed foods are the biggest culprits for both salt and sugar. Don't drink sugar. This means no juices, soft drinks or cordials. Read the label. Salt and sugar are hidden in even the healthiest foods, including nuts, sauces and breakfast cereals. Prepare own food. Restaurants use more salt than you think. If you start from scratch with fresh foods you can control your intake.
Professor Peter Clifton, head of nutritional interventions at Baker IDI Heart and Diabetes Institute says, "sugar is just another form of over-consumed calories — easily available and very palatable but no more metabolically deadly than starch or fat calories and certainly not equivalent to alcohol". "Alcohol toxicity is not just metabolic — it causes violence and road deaths and sugar in any of its forms cannot compete with this statistic," he said.
Written and revised by
Gerald Hurowitz, M.D.
Our doctors write and review articles for accuracy and keep them up to date.
health.am provides general information, not medical advice. Always consult a qualified health professional about your own health.
Explore health topics
More in this topic
Weight & Nutrition →
NewsExperts hope sugar, salt are next on FDA's target list
Now that the Food and Drug Administration has moved to banish most trans fats from the nation’s diet, some public health advocates are hopeful that two other beloved ingredients — sugar and salt — will be subject to…
18 November 2013
NewsFor disappointed sports fans, defeats increase consumption of fat and sugar
On the Monday following a big football game, fans of the losing team seem to load up on saturated fats and sugars, whereas supporters of the winning team opt for healthier foods, according to new research published in…
21 August 2013
NewsSugary drinks tied to obesity among preschoolers
Five-year-olds who drink sugar-sweetened sodas, sports drinks or juices every day are more likely to be obese than those who have sugar-sweetened beverages less often, according to a new study. Although the link between…


