Obese patients 'can have surgery'

Key points
- People who are obese should not have to lose weight before they can have surgery, a study suggests.
- Surgeons often refuse to operate on patients who are significantly overweight because of fears they are more likely to suffer complications.
- Patients are sometimes told to go away, lose weight and come back a few months later.
- But a study by doctors in Switzerland suggests this practice is unjustified.
People who are obese should not have to lose weight before they can have surgery, a study suggests.
Surgeons often refuse to operate on patients who are significantly overweight because of fears they are more likely to suffer complications.
Patients are sometimes told to go away, lose weight and come back a few months later.
But a study by doctors in Switzerland suggests this practice is unjustified.
Obese patients
Dr Pierre-Alain Clavien and colleagues at Zurich's University Hospital examined the cases of 6,300 patients who had undergone non-emergency operations.
More than one in eight of these patients was obese. A small number were severely obese.
The doctors found that, generally, the obese patients did not suffer any more complications than other patients.
A small number suffered more wound infections but this was not considered to be significant.
Dr Clavien said the findings refuted surgeons' claims that obese patients are more likely to suffer complications after surgery.
Writing in the journal The Lancet, he said: "Obesity alone is not a risk factor for postoperative complications.
"The regressive attitude towards general surgery in obese patients is no longer justified."
Dr Ian Campbell, chairman of the UK's National Obesity Forum, said: "Surgeons will now have to consider how they deal with obese patients.
"This study seems to reject their claims that obese patients suffer more complications after surgery."
Written and revised by
Gerald Hurowitz, M.D.
Our doctors write and review articles for accuracy and keep them up to date.
health.am provides general information, not medical advice. Always consult a qualified health professional about your own health.
Explore health topics
More in this topic
Weight & Nutrition →
NewsModel estimates risks and benefits of bariatric surgery for severely obese
A computerized model suggests that most morbidly obese individuals would likely live longer if they had gastric bypass surgery, according to a report in the January issue of Archives of Surgery, one of the JAMA/Archives…
19 January 2010
NewsIt can be predicted the reaction obese patients will have to a diet
The presence of increased body fat, and therefore higher levels of inflammatory substances in the blood, hinders the loss and maintenance of body weight; as shown by a research project of the University of Navarra…
25 November 2009
NewsWeight-Loss Surgery Works Even for Moderately Obese
Surgeons once recommended weight-loss surgery only for severely obese patients who failed to drop pounds with conventional weight-loss methods, but a review now finds that bariatric surgery helps the moderately obese…



