U.N. slams AIDS 'dissident' for attack on drugs

Key points
- United Nations aid agencies on Thursday slammed prominent AIDS "dissident" Matthias Rath for what they called his wrong and dangerous campaign against life-prolonging antiretroviral drugs.
- The maverick German doctor placed advertisements in international newspapers this week, days before he faces a court challenge in South Africa brought by the activist group Treatment Action Campaign (TAC).
- Rath's advertisements, which tout the benefits of vitamin therapy above antiretroviral (ARV) drugs he dismisses as toxic, are "wrong and misleading," U.N. agencies said.
- They issued a joint statement headlined "United Nations condemns irresponsible attack on antiretroviral therapy."
United Nations aid agencies on Thursday slammed prominent AIDS "dissident" Matthias Rath for what they called his wrong and dangerous campaign against life-prolonging antiretroviral drugs.
The maverick German doctor placed advertisements in international newspapers this week, days before he faces a court challenge in South Africa brought by the activist group Treatment Action Campaign (TAC).
Rath's advertisements, which tout the benefits of vitamin therapy above antiretroviral (ARV) drugs he dismisses as toxic, are "wrong and misleading," U.N. agencies said.
They issued a joint statement headlined "United Nations condemns irresponsible attack on antiretroviral therapy."
"Misrepresentations of this sort are both dangerous and unhelpful," declared the World Health Organization (WHO), the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS known as UNAIDS, and the U.N. Children's Fund (UNICEF).
"In countries where it is widely available, antiretroviral therapy has turned AIDS from a 'death sentence' into a chronic but manageable disease," they said.
Rath, who runs a vitamin company, and other AIDS "dissidents" have cast doubt on the links between HIV and AIDS and the use of drugs to treat the disease.
He accuses the United States, Britain, the World Bank and the United Nations of promoting expensive drugs on behalf of the pharmaceutical industry, and claims that TAC is a front for the "drug cartel."
His foundation, which has offices in Germany, the United States and the Netherlands, earlier this year ran a campaign in South African newspapers, arguing antiretrovirals are poisons that kill and cause deformities in babies.
TAC, South Africa's most influential activist group, is suing the Rath Foundation for alleged defamation and what it says are lies about AIDS drugs.
The U.N. agencies, which are trying to increase access in poor countries to such drugs, also denounced Rath's Web Site and advertisements for using quotes and information from U.N. agencies "out of context."
Studies on the role of micronutrient supplements on the course of HIV/AIDS have been inconclusive, the statement said.
"Vitamins and nutritional supplements alone can not take the place of comprehensive treatment and care for people living with HIV/AIDS," it said. Such care should include treatment for infections, antiretroviral therapy and a good, balanced diet.
"Antiretroviral therapy has been shown in numerous studies to reduce the replication of HIV in the body, reduce the incidence of opportunistic infections and AIDS-related illness and improve quality of life," the statement added.
Written and revised by
Andrey Nailor, M.D.
Our doctors write and review articles for accuracy and keep them up to date.
health.am provides general information, not medical advice. Always consult a qualified health professional about your own health.
Explore health topics
More in this topic
Infections, HIV & STIs →
NewsBrazil to lose from AIDS patent move -- drugs body
The global pharmaceutical industry body IFPMA warned on Wednesday that Brazil's decision to break a U.S.-held AIDS drug patent would turn foreign firms against cooperating with the country's health programmes. In a…
8 July 2005
NewsChina AIDS victims fight bad drugs, ineptitude
Wang Shuling's skin is stretched tight over her bones and her body shakes like a leaf, to the point that she cannot walk on her own and her hands are not steady enough to lift a glass of water. Wang, 50, has AIDS and is…
1 July 2005
NewsGeneric drugs key to uphill AIDS fight
Generic drugs hold the key to AIDS treatment in the developing world, although a target of getting 3 million people on therapy by the end of 2005 may now be out of reach, according to the World Health Organization. Hans…
22 June 2005




