Stun guns may cause fatal chaotic heart rhythm
Key points
- Stun guns used by law enforcement officers may rarely cause lethal heart rhythm disturbances, what doctors call cardiac arrhythmia, investigators in Canada report, based on animal experiments.
- Kumaraswamy Nanthakumar and colleagues at the University of Toronto used pigs to more thoroughly evaluate the risks associated with stun guns.
- During 150 stun gun discharges, 74 resulted in abnormal stimulation of the heart muscle.
- These findings, the authors say, suggest that there "exists the possibility of serious" heart rhythm disturbances during stun gun device discharges in structurally normal hearts under intense stress.
Stun guns used by law enforcement officers may rarely cause lethal heart rhythm disturbances, what doctors call cardiac arrhythmia, investigators in Canada report, based on animal experiments.
Dr. Kumaraswamy Nanthakumar and colleagues at the University of Toronto used pigs to more thoroughly evaluate the risks associated with stun guns. They implanted heart catheters and blood pressure devices into the animals.
During 150 stun gun discharges, 74 resulted in abnormal stimulation of the heart muscle. The danger was apparent only for thoracic discharges (administered parallel to the long axis of the heart on the chest wall) as opposed to nonthoracic (away from the chest, across the abdomen).
When epinephrine was administered to the animals, to simulate the stress that targeted individuals may face during the incident, one out of 16 discharges induced ventricular fibrillation - a condition in which the heart muscle quivers instead of contracting normally - and one caused ventricular tachycardia - a rapid, abnormal heart rhythm.
These findings, the authors say, suggest that there "exists the possibility of serious" heart rhythm disturbances during stun gun device discharges in structurally normal hearts under intense stress. Moreover, they add, there is heightened risk for individuals with pre-existing structural heart disease.
A related study suggests that cocaine use may attenuate that risk. Dr. Patrick Tchou at the Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Ohio, and associates again used a pig model, and observed that cocaine appears to increase the ability of the heart to withstand the effects of the stun gun.
SOURCE: Journal of the American College of Cardiology August 2006.
Written and revised by
Gerald Hurowitz, M.D.
Our doctors write and review articles for accuracy and keep them up to date.
health.am provides general information, not medical advice. Always consult a qualified health professional about your own health.
Explore health topics
More in this topic
Heart & Blood Vessels →
NewsResearchers find process that clears cholesterol and could reverse major cause of heart attack
Researchers at the University of Ottawa Heart Institute (UOHI) have discovered that an ancient pathway called autophagy also mobilizes and exports cholesterol from cells. A team led by Yves Marcel, PhD, Director of the…
9 September 2011
NewsAll-cause mortality rates are lower among moderate drinkers than among abstainers
The author of this paper set out to determine the extent to which potential "errors" in many early epidemiologic studies led to erroneous conclusions about an inverse association between moderate drinking and coronary…
12 July 2011
NewsNovel approach yields new insights into the causes of pre-eclampsia
An exciting collaboration between the Universities of Cambridge and Nottingham has resulted in new insights into the hypertension that frequently blights pregnancy. The results, published in the journal Nature [online…
