Would You Allow Your Child to Participate in Medical Research?

Advances in medicine – new treatments, cures, vaccines and medicines – are driven by research involving humans. But when it comes to medical research that requires children to be involved, researchers often struggle to find participants.

The reason? Many parents are often unwilling to allow their children to take part in medical research, fearing that they may be harmed or used as “guinea pigs,” according to a report released today by the University of Michigan C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital National Poll on Children’s Health.

In fact, the report finds that only 30 percent of parents are willing to allow their children to participate in research involving a new medication. In contrast, 77 percent of parents want only FDA-approved medicines for their children. This finding reveals a large gap between the proportion of parents who want safe medicines for their children, and those who are willing to have their children take part in research that could ultimately produce information about medicine safety.

“We know that parents, quite reasonably, may be concerned about having their children participate in medical research,” says Matthew M. Davis, M.D., M.A.P.P., director of the National Poll on Children’s Health. “Parents, however, may not realize how pediatric research has saved lives and helped lives. Research has led to the creation of vaccines, many of which have helped eradicate diseases like diphtheria, polio and small pox within the borders of our country. That’s all thanks to vaccines that have been tested in clinical studies in which children have played a major role.”

Clinical trials during the past 30 years are also responsible for improved survival rates for common childhood cancers, from less than 50 percent to 85 percent, says Valerie Castle, M.D., chair of the Department of Pediatrics and the Ravitz Foundation Professor of Pediatrics and Communicable Diseases at the U-M Health System.

“Parents, physicians and other advocates in the community must encourage a national discourse on the importance of research, and also improved funding for pediatric research to ensure more progress can be made in treating and preventing childhood diseases.” she says.

The National Poll on Children’s Health finds:
• 77 percent of parents want only FDA-approved medicines for their children, but only 30 percent say they will allow their children to participate in research.
• Many parents are willing to consider children’s participation in research if the risk of harm is small.
• 92 percent of parents have never been asked to have their children participate in research.

The report, however, does reveal some very promising results for researchers: Twenty-five percent of parents polled indicated that they would consider allowing their child to participate in research as a healthy volunteer and another 36 percent would consider it if their child had a particular disease being studied.