Is Your Back Pain Caused by Herniated Disc? Single Test Can’t Tell

While lower back pain ranks as a common cause of disability in the United States, determining what causes a person’s back pain is often challenging. A new Cochrane review on diagnosing back pain finds that no single diagnostic test is good at discriminating between patients who have a herniated disc and patients who do not, according to lead author Danielle van der Windt.

Having accurate diagnostic information is important for clinicians to discuss the potential cause of pain with patients and make better decisions about pain management, said Van der Windt, an epidemiologist at the Arthritis Research Campaign at the National Primary Care Centre at Keele University in Staffordshire, England.

“The straight leg-raising test, for example, is often used in clinical practice, but results are positive in many individuals who do not have a disc herniation, or negative in those who do,” Van der Windt said. “Clinicians need a combination of questions about the patient’s history and diagnostic tests that can help them reassure patients or inform them about the next step in the process.

“The consequences of inadequate testing can certainly be that patients may be unnecessarily referred for imaging studies (CT, MRI or other scan), or patients who should be scanned are referred too late or not at all,” she said. “This means that there may be some people who could have benefited from early surgery, though this proportion will be small, given that many patients respond well to conservative treatment.”

This review appears in the current issue of The Cochrane Library, a publication of The Cochrane Collaboration, an international organization that evaluates research in all aspects of health care. Systematic reviews draw evidence-based conclusions about medical practice after considering both the content and quality of existing trials on a topic.

Healthy discs are spongy cushions of cartilage that fill the spaces between vertebrae in the spine. They act as shock absorbers for the spine and allow flexibility. A herniated disc can occur when a disc incurs damage because of trauma or stress and bulges outside of its normal position to press on a nerve. This can result in pain that radiates down to the lower leg — also called sciatica.

In other conditions, including osteoporosis and similar aging disorders, bony structures could press on nerves, causing this pain.

Van der Windt and her colleagues throughout Europe, New Zealand and North America conducted an extensive search of the evidence. Ultimately, the team focused on 19 studies that included about 8,000 participants.

Even so, Van der Windt said she was disappointed at the lack of good research. Many of the biggest studies date back to the 1960s and 1970s. Moreover, while being able to diagnose a herniated disc is desirable at a patient’s first contact with a clinician, only a single study occurred in a primary care setting. Almost all study participants were surgical patients.