News

EU Goes Light on E-Cigarettes

Gerald Hurowitz, M.D.Published 10 October 20131 min read

Key points

Electronic cigarettes won't be tightly regulated as medical devices in Europe, lawmakers there decided.
Officials had proposed restricting direct sales to consumers, classifying the devices alongside nicotine patches and other smoking cessation products that require a prescription.
The European Parliament struck down that proposal, though, voting Tuesday to regulate them much as they do conventional cigarettes, with only the usual marketing, packaging, and 18-and-older age restrictions.
While the lawmakers also voted to tighten restrictions on smoking tobacco packaging and menthol flavoring, e-cigarettes were considered the main question.

Electronic cigarettes won't be tightly regulated as medical devices in Europe, lawmakers there decided.

Officials had proposed restricting direct sales to consumers, classifying the devices alongside nicotine patches and other smoking cessation products that require a prescription.

The European Parliament struck down that proposal, though, voting Tuesday to regulate them much as they do conventional cigarettes, with only the usual marketing, packaging, and 18-and-older age restrictions.

While the lawmakers also voted to tighten restrictions on smoking tobacco packaging and menthol flavoring, e-cigarettes were considered the main question.

In the U.S., the FDA is also weighing how to deal with the increasingly popular nicotine-vapor devices

The agency has said it will issue proposed regulations on e-cigarettes soon, a move that was widely expected by the end of October but may be delayed by shutdown-related furloughs at the chronically understaffed agency.

It tried to regulate e-cigarettes as medical devices but acquiesced in 2011 to an appeals court ruling that as long as no health claims are made for the products they only fit under the agency's authority to regulate tobacco.

Individual European Union member states have attempted to quash sales through tight regulation or outright bans, but these have typically been struck down by legal action.

The amended Tobacco Products Directive now has to be agreed upon by E.U. government ministers and voted on again by the parliament, but no meaningful opposition is expected.

These moves have been carefully watched as other public health agencies around the world are trying to get a handle on e-cigarettes, which are often targeted to smokers wanting to quit.

A recent study indicated the devices were at least equal to nicotine patches in that regard, although other studies show there still is an impact on lung function despite elimination of carcinogenic tobacco smoke.

The FDA has previously warned e-cigarette manufacturers against making claims that the devices help smokers quit.

###

Crystal Phend
Senior Staff Writer, MedPage Today

Written and revised by

Gerald Hurowitz, M.D.

Our doctors write and review articles for accuracy and keep them up to date.

health.am provides general information, not medical advice. Always consult a qualified health professional about your own health.

Explore health topics

EU Goes Light on E-Cigarettes

Gerald Hurowitz, M.D.Published 10 October 20131 min read

Key points

Electronic cigarettes won't be tightly regulated as medical devices in Europe, lawmakers there decided.
Officials had proposed restricting direct sales to consumers, classifying the devices alongside nicotine patches and other smoking cessation products that require a prescription.
The European Parliament struck down that proposal, though, voting Tuesday to regulate them much as they do conventional cigarettes, with only the usual marketing, packaging, and 18-and-older age restrictions.
While the lawmakers also voted to tighten restrictions on smoking tobacco packaging and menthol flavoring, e-cigarettes were considered the main question.